Is the U.S. Post Office Broken Beyond Repair?

post office problems

by Tim on September 14, 2011

The US Postal System has made its way into the news once again and its problems just seem to get bigger with each month that goes by.  Unless a solution passes Congress, these issues will leave the USPS broke and jeopardize the nationalized mail system altogether.

US Post Office Problems

  •  Congress micromanages the post office.  A surefire way to run a bureaucracy into the ground is to make it so that changes are difficult to implement.  When decisions have to come from the top (that is, passed by congress) you can bet that it will take a while and that the solutions will come much later than needed.  Flexibility is why small businesses (like UPS and FedEx) are able to adapt to changes in the marketplace; the lack of flexibility is one of the reasons why the U.S. Postal Service has so many problems right now.
  • According to PBS, volume is down 22% from five years ago.  This caused the Postal Service to face losses of $8 billion for the second year in a row.  Losses like this aren’t sustainable; especially if you don’t make efforts to change the way you do business.
  • The USPS is in risk of defaulting on their $5.5 billion payment that is due on September 30.  This payment is to pay for future health care for retired postal workers, and unless Congress ‘takes action’ (i.e. lend money from some other resource or reverse the 2006 bill that required pre-payment on future health care benefits) they will technically default on this bill.  This isn’t something that will cause the mail to stop in its tracks, but if the lack of capital continues to be a problem, the USPS will have problems meeting payroll.
  • Speaking of payroll, this is one of the most expensive problems for the Post Office.  Currently , the USPS spends about 80% of its budget on labor expenses.  Compare this to the 53% that UPS spends as well as 32% Fed Ex spends on its labor.  It’s clear to see that making a cut in this part of the budget means that people will lose jobs, and see decreases in pay as well as other benefits in order for the USPS to stay solvent.

Proposed Solutions for the US Postal Service

The postmaster general, Patrick Donahoe said that the USPS is trying to push measures through Congress that will help to address these issues.  Donahoe proposed a series of measures that would cut costs for the USPS, hopefully cutting its projected $9 billion deficit this fiscal year.


Eliminating Saturday Mail Delivery – This is estimated to save the USPS $3 billion dollars.  It’s a solutions that needs to be passed in my opinion.  We can all live with one less day of mail pickup.  If someone needs to send out mail on Saturday, I don’t see why driving to the Post Office would be a problem.  Cutting Saturday delivery saves billions and should be passed by Congress soon.

Closing Up to 3,700 USPS locations – The proposal by Mr. Donahoe suggests that the USPS close 3,700 branches in smaller towns, replacing them with automated centers that are operated from local businesses.  It makes sense to cut the less profitable and smaller branches, but it will be inconvenient for those residents who have to talk with a machine rather than an actual person.

Laying off 120,000 workers – Donahoe also suggested to Congress that 120,000 USPS workers should be laid off and that an additional 100,000 jobs absorbed through the years to come.   With over 650,000 employees in the USPS, the proposed labor cuts represent a 33% drop in employment.   This would bring the total employment below 450,000 or nearly half of its size when compared to a decade ago (900,000 employees).

How would you solve the problems?  Would you be OK with one less day of delivery?  How would you feel if your local post office was replaced with an automated machine?

{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }

krantcents September 14, 2011

Saturday delivery is not important to me since there are so many other choices. Making the USPS more efficient may be another choice.

Reply

Tim September 15, 2011

I say bring in the competition! Having a monopoly on mail service is the antithesis of efficiency in this business!

Reply

zella January 5, 2012

I worked for the Postal Service for 31 year and retired in 2005. I delivered mail for all of those years and had 3 different routes in that time. Most people do not really understand the postal service at all. Everyone that wants to make a comment, negative or positive should read up on the USPS history to understand why they are were they are now. Unfourtunatly, Congress has a strangle hold on the USPS. That will kill it if nothing else does. I can tell you up front one thing you do not want to happen is to have the Postal Service privitized. You think you are paying a lot of money now to send first class mail, just let it become privatized and see what you will pay for services like that. Today mail goes to every business and household in the United States everyday. Once it is privatized…well don’t expect to get mail everyday. I agree that there are small post offices around the country that should be closed and there are plenty of middle and top management jobs from head quarters on down to the local post office that could be cut. There are lots of ways to save money; but fist the Postal Service needs to be allowed flexability to do what it should do. I could write a book, but there is not enough room here. :>) I hope this helps a little.

Reply

cashflowmantra September 15, 2011

I would be totally OK with only receiving mail on Monday through Friday and using automated machines for most of my needs. I would even be OK with receiving mail 3 days per week. I am so busy it usually just sits on my desk for a week until I can sort through it and throw away anyway. I pay bills online.

Reply

Tim September 15, 2011

Haha, I know what you mean. Unless I’m expecting a package from Amazon or something…which, come to think of it, usually is delivered by UPS or FedEx :)

Reply

20's Finances September 15, 2011

It is quite unfortunate, but it is a changing of tides. It only makes sense with the popularity of UPS and Fedex that there will be less jobs and USPS will have to cut back. It is sad to think about how many jobs are lost, but there have also been many other jobs created with UPS and Fedex. I would be interested to see the figures and if there has been increase or decrease when considering the major shipping companies.

Reply

Tim September 15, 2011

Good thought. I don’t know if total number of jobs created has actually gone up as a whole. With the most recent recession, businesses have definitely cut back on advertising via mail, which really hit the USPS revenue big time.

Reply

Paula @ AffordAnything.org September 19, 2011

“Is the U.S. Post Office Broken Beyond Repair?” — short answer: YES!

I’m totally fine with the idea of USPS halting Saturday delivery. Heck, they can even switch to a Mon/Wed/Fri schedule if it saves money (though that might cause them to lose customers).

I’m not such a fan of them shutting down unprofitable locations in rural areas, since talking to a machine is next-to-impossible and shutting down rural postal locations might drive more people to the city. However, they should totally shut down locations in crowded/urban areas, since the residents there have the option of driving an extra 5 miles if they really want to talk to a human being.

I have at least 3 post offices equidistant from my home that I can choose to drive to in roughly similar amounts of time. Granted, I live in the heart of a city, but still … isn’t that a bit much??

Reply

Leave a Comment

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

{ 2 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: